When it comes to pizza, Passaic, New Jersey holds its own among the best. As part of the legendary tri-state pizza belt, Passaic sits right in the middle of one of the most celebrated pizza regions in the world — rivaling even Italy, the birthplace of pizza itself.
At Bella Pizza, known by many as the best pizza in Passaic, we’ve seen local tastes evolve while traditions stay strong. Whether you’re a die-hard fan of the classic New York-style slice or someone who likes to experiment with bold toppings, pizza here is more than just a meal — it’s part of our culture.
Based on our own customer orders, local trends, and a recent regional survey of pizza lovers, here are New Jersey’s top pizza toppings, ranked not by popularity, but by how passionately people love them.
Order More & Save!
3.00 Off any order of 30.00 or more! 5.00 Off any order of 50.00 or more!
8.00 Off any order of 80.00 or more!
1. Pepperoni – The Iconic Favorite
It’s the slice that shows up in every movie, commercial, emoji, and meme — pepperoni pizza is the standard bearer of American pizza culture.
At Bella Pizza, we’ve served thousands of pepperoni pies to customers in Passaic and beyond. The crispy edges, salty flavor, and perfect balance with melty cheese and tomato sauce make this topping a timeless classic.
Whether you’re ordering for a party or just yourself, you can’t go wrong with pepperoni.
2. Mushrooms – Earthy, Healthy, and Rising in Popularity
Not too long ago, mushrooms were a niche topping. Today? They’re among the most ordered vegetarian options across New Jersey.
According to our team at Bella Pizza — also delivering to Garfield and surrounding towns — mushroom pizza is especially popular among vegetarians and customers looking for something savory, yet meat-free. It’s a healthy, flavor-packed choice that complements everything from white pies to sausage-heavy slices.
3. Spinach on White Pizza – A Creamy, Italian Classic
Spinach might not be everyone’s first choice — but once you try it on a white slice, it’s a game-changer.
At Bella Pizza, where we’re also known for some of the best Italian food near Hasbrouck Heights, spinach-topped white pizza has grown into a customer favorite. Made with ricotta, mozzarella, and a hint of garlic (no red sauce), it’s perfect for those who want something lighter, creamier, and full of rich flavor.
4. Sausage – Bold, Hearty, and Always Satisfying
Sausage pizza is a top pick for meat lovers — and its popularity isn’t slowing down. Whether crumbled or sliced, Italian sausage adds a savory depth and spicy kick to every bite.
At Bella Pizza, serving customers in Bogota, Passaic, and beyond, our sausage pies are especially popular in combo orders with mushrooms or onions. If you’re a fan of bold flavors, this one’s for you.
5. Buffalo Chicken – A Modern Favorite with a Spicy Twist
One of the fastest-growing topping trends across New Jersey is buffalo chicken pizza. Tangy, spicy, and loaded with flavor, it’s like enjoying your two favorite game-day snacks — wings and pizza — in one delicious slice.
At Bella Pizza, we serve up our buffalo chicken pies with just the right amount of heat. It’s perfect for customers looking for a high-protein topping without the heaviness of sausage or pepperoni.
Try the Best Pizza in Passaic at Bella Pizza Today
Whether you’re a fan of the classics or looking to try something new, Bella Pizza has something for everyone:
Hand-tossed, stone-oven pizzas
Fresh toppings, rich sauces, and creamy cheeses
Full Italian menu including pastas, salads, wings, and more
Fast, friendly delivery throughout Passaic, Garfield, Bogota, and nearby towns
Visit us at 197 Boulevard, Hasbrouck Heights, NJ — or order online and get your favorite toppings delivered hot and fresh to your door.
Order now and taste why locals say Bella Pizza serves the best pizza in Passaic.
Looking for the best 24-hour pizza in Rutherford, NJ?
Tap below to call or order online. Bella Pizza is open 24/7 in Rutherford — your favorite local slice is waiting!