When it comes to the greatest pizza debates in America, the conversation almost always starts with New York or Naples. Ask a proud New Yorker, and they’ll swear nothing beats a Brooklyn slice. Ask a purist, and they’ll point straight to Naples, Italy — the birthplace of pizza.
But if you ask the locals in the Garden State, they’ll tell you the truth loud and clear: the best pizza isn’t in New York or Italy — it’s right here in New Jersey.
And they’ve got a strong case.
According to the team at Bella Pizza, known for the best pizza South Hackensack, Bogota, and Garfield have to offer, Jersey pizza is more than just food — it’s a cultural staple, a neighborhood institution, and an everyday craving. From the corner shop in Garfield to a classic tomato pie in Trenton, New Jersey pizza has carved out its own identity in the world of pies.
Let’s dive into what makes New Jersey pizza unique — with the help of Bella Pizza, proudly serving some of the best pizzeria slices in South Hackensack, Bogota, and beyond.
Order More & Save!
3.00 Off any order of 30.00 or more! 5.00 Off any order of 50.00 or more!
8.00 Off any order of 80.00 or more!
Understanding the “Jersey Pie”
Search for New Jersey pizza online, and you’ll get a mix of results — from neighborhood slices to fancy white pies, Sicilian trays to grandma-style squares. But if you really want to understand what defines authentic Jersey pizza, you have to start with the Trenton Tomato Pie.
The Trenton Tomato Pie — Jersey’s Signature Style
According to Bella Pizza — the go-to pizzeria in Garfield and South Hackensack — the Trenton Tomato Pie is the foundation of NJ’s pizza history. Unlike traditional pizza where the sauce is spread first, the Trenton-style flips the script:
First: the dough
Second: the cheese
Third: your toppings
Finally: the sauce — added on top
Yes, the sauce goes last — and that’s not a mistake. This style creates a pizza that’s bold in flavor, lighter on grease, and distinctly New Jersey.
If that sounds familiar, it should. Other iconic styles like Chicago deep-dish and Detroit-style pizza also place sauce on top. But New Jersey keeps it thin, with a pliable, chewy crust — somewhere between a Neapolitan base and a New York foldable slice.
The Secret Is in the Crust
When it comes to crust, New Jersey nails the balance. According to the owners of Bella Pizza — the best pizzeria in Bogota and Garfield — a classic Jersey pie has:
A round shape (no rectangles here!)
A hand-tossed, thin, but soft crust
Chewiness with just enough crisp on the bottom
It’s not quite the ultra-crunchy thin crust you’ll find in California, and not the thick sponge of a Sicilian square — it’s uniquely Jersey.
What gives it that iconic texture? Experts point to a few key things:
High-gluten flour
Proper water content (yes, even NJ tap water is part of the magic!)
Hot ovens that bake quickly
Ingredients that Matter
In New Jersey, every ingredient is intentional. From the rich, sweet tomato sauces to the perfect blend of mozzarella and provolone, pizzerias across the state take pride in keeping their pies flavorful and consistent.
According to the team at Bella Pizza — the best pizza spot in South Hackensack — it’s not about having 50 toppings or over-complicating the pie. It’s about quality, tradition, and perfect execution.
Takeout Pizza in New Jersey: More Than Just Convenience
What makes NJ pizza even more legendary is its availability. From beachside slices down the Jersey Shore to late-night pies in Garfield or Hackensack, takeout pizza is part of everyday life.
Bella Pizza, known for top-rated take-out and delivery in Bogota and South Hackensack, has become a household name by offering:
Fast service without compromising quality
Classic and specialty pies made fresh daily
Affordable meals for families, students, and late-night foodies
Final Slice: The Jersey Pizza Identity
Whether you’re team Brooklyn, Naples, or New Haven, there’s no denying that New Jersey pizza has earned its spot at the top. Thanks to unique styles like the Trenton Tomato Pie, high-quality ingredients, and old-school pizzerias that still do things the right way — Jersey continues to win hearts (and stomachs).
If you haven’t tried a true New Jersey pie yet, now’s the time.
Visit Bella Pizza Today – Serving the Best Pizza in South Hackensack, Bogota, and Garfield
From classic tomato pies to white slices, veggie combos to meat-lovers’ feasts — Bella Pizza is your one-stop shop for authentic New Jersey flavor.
Visit us or place your takeout order today
Fast delivery available across South Hackensack, Bogota & Garfield
Call now for the best slice in town!
Looking for the best 24-hour pizza in New Jersey?
Tap below to call or order online. Bella Pizza is open 24/7 in New Jersey — your favorite local slice is waiting!