For decades, New York has reigned supreme as the pizza capital of America. But recently, something historic happened — and pizza lovers in New Jersey are still celebrating. According to rankings released by Food & Wine Magazine, New Jersey has officially been named the #1 pizza state in the country, dethroning the long-standing champ, New York.
Surprised? You’re not alone. But for locals in Hasbrouck Heights and Wood Ridge, this news only confirms what they’ve known for years: Jersey pizza isn’t just good — it’s world-class. And there’s no better place to experience it than at one of the best dine-in pizza spots around: Bella Pizza.
Let’s break down how New Jersey took the title and why Bella Pizza has become the go-to choice for pizza dine-in near Hasbrouck Heights and Wood Ridge.
Order More & Save!
3.00 Off any order of 30.00 or more! 5.00 Off any order of 50.00 or more!
8.00 Off any order of 80.00 or more!
The Pandemic Changed Everything — Including Pizza Quality
According to the team at Bella Pizza, a top-rated dine-in pizzeria near Hasbrouck Heights, the COVID-19 pandemic hit New York hard. Famous pizzerias in NYC shut down, lost key staff, or struggled to maintain quality as restrictions and staff shortages took their toll.
Meanwhile in New Jersey, restaurants like Bella Pizza adapted quickly — pivoting to takeout and delivery without compromising on quality. Locations in Hasbrouck Heights, Wood Ridge, and beyond became community staples during tough times, offering comforting meals and consistency when it mattered most.
That consistency helped many Jersey pizzerias retain loyal customers, and even grow their fan base.
Versatility Is What Put NJ Pizza on Top
If NYC is known for its classic foldable slice, New Jersey is known for its diversity. According to Bella Pizza, which also serves customers looking for dine-in pizza in Wood Ridge, versatility in flavor and crust styles helped set NJ apart.
From Trenton Tomato Pies, to Buffalo Chicken slices, to artisan-style white pizzas with spinach and ricotta, New Jersey offers more than just the basics — and it does them all well.
While NYC has largely stuck to its signature look and feel, NJ pizzerias like Bella Pizza have embraced modern toppings, gluten-free crusts, and new twists — all while preserving old-school quality.
The Italian Roots Run Deep in Hasbrouck Heights and Wood Ridge
Another major reason for Jersey’s pizza success? Its deep Italian-American heritage.
In places like Hasbrouck Heights and Wood Ridge, Italian traditions run through the community — and you can taste it in every bite of Bella Pizza. From handmade dough prepared daily to traditional sauces using local, fresh ingredients, the pizza here isn’t just food — it’s part of a long-standing cultural identity.
Bella Pizza, praised as one of the best dine-in pizza restaurants in Wood Ridge, honors this history with authentic recipes and an atmosphere that makes every visit feel like home.
The Victory Over New York Wasn’t Even Close
In the 2021 Food & Wine rankings, New Jersey took the top spot, followed by Connecticut — with New York falling to third place. For many in Hasbrouck Heights and Wood Ridge, this confirmed what they’d known all along: Jersey pizza deserves respect.
Even New York restaurateurs took the loss hard. Some refused to believe it, but others admitted what many already suspected — New Jersey’s pizza scene has been quietly improving, and now it’s finally getting the recognition it deserves.
Want to Taste the Best? Dine In at Bella Pizza Today
If you’re searching for the best dine-in pizza in Hasbrouck Heights or Wood Ridge, Bella Pizza is your spot. With fresh, handcrafted pies, friendly service, and a welcoming atmosphere, it’s the perfect place to experience award-winning Jersey pizza firsthand.
Visit Bella Pizza today — the place that proves New Jersey truly is the #1 pizza state.
Check out their menu, enjoy a slice, and see why Hasbrouck Heights and Wood Ridge are proud to call it their own.
Looking for the best 24-hour pizza in Hasbrouck Heights?
Tap below to call or order online. Bella Pizza is open 24/7 in Hasbrouck Heights — your favorite local slice is waiting!