When it comes to top-tier pizza, few places can compete with the tri-state area — and especially New Jersey. From classic slices to creative pies, the Garden State has become one of the most iconic pizza regions in the world, often rivaling even the traditions of Italy itself.
At Bella Pizza, proudly serving East Rutherford, Passaic, Moonachie, and Hackensack, we’ve seen it all — from timeless pepperoni to adventurous pineapple. As one of the best pizzerias in East Rutherford, we’re always listening to our customers and keeping an eye on what toppings New Jersey pizza lovers can’t get enough of.
Based on recent surveys and daily customer favorites, here are New Jersey’s most popular pizza toppings, served fresh and hot from your neighborhood go-to: Bella Pizza.
Order More & Save!
3.00 Off any order of 30.00 or more! 5.00 Off any order of 50.00 or more!
8.00 Off any order of 80.00 or more!
1. Pepperoni – The Classic Crowd-Pleaser
It’s impossible to start a pizza toppings list without the undisputed king — pepperoni. Whether you love it or just expect to see it, pepperoni is practically the default pizza in pop culture, movies, and even emojis.
At Bella Pizza, the best pizzeria serving Passaic and East Rutherford, our customers keep this topping at the top for good reason. The crispy edges, salty bite, and perfect pairing with mozzarella and sauce make pepperoni slices fly out of our ovens daily.
2. Mushrooms – The Savory Veggie Favorite
Mushrooms have quietly become a vegetarian hero across New Jersey’s pizza scene. Their rich, umami flavor and tender texture make them a popular choice for those who prefer to skip the meat but still want something hearty and satisfying.
According to our team at Bella Pizza, also delivering to Garfield, mushroom-topped pizzas are trending more than ever, especially among health-conscious customers and veggie lovers alike.
3. Spinach on White Pizza – Creamy and Fresh
Love white pizza? Then chances are you’ve tried (or need to try) spinach as a topping.
Spinach pairs perfectly with ricotta, mozzarella, and garlic-based white sauces, offering a light, fresh, and slightly earthy flavor. At Bella Pizza, known for some of the best Italian food in Hasbrouck Heights and East Rutherford, we serve tons of spinach-based pies to customers looking for a creamier, cheese-forward experience without red sauce.
4. Sausage – The Meat Lover’s Must-Have
Right behind pepperoni in popularity is Italian sausage — the go-to for anyone who loves savory, spiced meat on their slice.
At Bella Pizza, we’ve seen a big rise in sausage pizza orders throughout towns like Bogota and Moonachie. Whether crumbled or sliced, sausage adds depth and boldness, especially when paired with mushrooms or green peppers.
5. Buffalo Chicken – Spicy, Tangy, and Filling
If you want a topping with a kick, buffalo chicken pizza delivers every time. Tangy, spicy, and often paired with ranch or blue cheese drizzle, it’s like having wings and pizza in one — no dipping sauce required.
At Bella Pizza, where we specialize in modern takes on classic pies, buffalo chicken has become a go-to choice for customers who want something hearty, flavorful, and full of personality.
Discover Your Favorite Topping at the Best Pizzeria in East Rutherford
Whether you stick to the classics or like to explore new combinations, Bella Pizza offers the perfect canvas for your next craving. As the best pizzeria in East Rutherford, we’re proud to serve up:
Fresh, hand-tossed pizzas
High-quality toppings
Classic Italian dishes & sides
Delivery to Passaic, Hackensack, Moonachie & more
Visit us at 197 Boulevard, Hasbrouck Heights, NJ – or order online and get your favorite toppings delivered hot and fresh to your door.
Try your perfect slice today — only at Bella Pizza, where East Rutherford comes for the best pizza in town.
Looking for the best 24-hour pizza in Rutherford, NJ?
Tap below to call or order online. Bella Pizza is open 24/7 in Rutherford — your favorite local slice is waiting!