When it comes to great pizza, few regions rival the Tri-State area — and New Jersey in particular takes pride in its deep-rooted pizza culture. From Passaic to East Rutherford, pizza isn’t just food — it’s tradition, family, and flavor baked into every slice.
At Bella Pizza, we’re proud to serve our community with some of the best pizza delivery in East Rutherford, Moonachie, Hackensack, and beyond. Over the years, we’ve seen customer preferences evolve, new topping combinations go viral, and classic flavors hold strong.
So, what do New Jersey pizza lovers really prefer on their pies?
We asked — and here are the top toppings that keep our customers coming back slice after slice.
Order More & Save!
3.00 Off any order of 30.00 or more! 5.00 Off any order of 50.00 or more!
8.00 Off any order of 80.00 or more!
Pepperoni – The Classic That Never Quits
Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice or ordering pies for a party, pepperoni pizza continues to reign supreme. Its rich, salty flavor and crispy edges make it a timeless favorite.
It’s more than just popular — it’s iconic. You’ll find pepperoni pizza emojis, cartoons, and movie scenes, all celebrating this beloved topping. At Bella Pizza, it’s one of the most requested slices on the menu.
Mushrooms – The Vegetarian Favorite
According to our team at Bella Pizza, voted the best pizza delivery in Garfield, mushroom pizza is on the rise — especially among vegetarian and health-conscious customers.
Earthy, savory, and perfect alongside melted mozzarella, mushrooms add an extra layer of depth and umami that’s hard to beat. Whether you pair them with sausage or go full veggie — it’s a winning combo.
Spinach on White Pizza – Creamy, Cheesy, and Fresh
Spinach might be polarizing for some, but for white pizza lovers, it’s the star of the show.
Our white pizza — made without tomato sauce — features a luscious blend of ricotta and mozzarella, olive oil, garlic, and tender spinach. As the top choice for Italian food in Hasbrouck Heights, we proudly serve this lighter-yet-indulgent alternative to traditional red pies.
Sausage – Hearty and Flavorful
When it comes to meaty toppings, sausage holds a special place in New Jersey’s pizza culture.
At Bella Pizza, we use premium sausage that’s juicy, well-seasoned, and perfectly paired with our slightly sweet red sauce. Whether it’s sliced, crumbled, or spicy, it’s a go-to for meat lovers across Bogota, Moonachie, and East Rutherford.
Buffalo Chicken – A Flavor Explosion
Craving something bold? Buffalo chicken pizza brings the heat — and our customers love it.
At Bella Pizza, known as the best pizzeria in Passaic and East Rutherford, we craft our buffalo chicken slices with marinated chicken breast, tangy buffalo sauce, and just the right amount of cheese. It’s like your favorite game-day wings — but on a pizza.
This spicy twist has become one of our fastest-growing specialty pies — and for good reason.
Discover Your New Favorite Topping at Bella Pizza
Whether you’re a traditionalist who sticks with pepperoni, or you’re ready to explore bold toppings like spinach or buffalo chicken — we’ve got the perfect pie for you.
Why Bella Pizza?
Fresh dough made daily
Locally sourced ingredients
Quick & reliable delivery in East Rutherford, Hackensack, Moonachie, Passaic & beyond
Classic and creative pizza options for every craving
Order now online or by phone — and let Bella Pizza bring New Jersey’s favorite flavors straight to your door.
Bella Pizza – Delivering more than pizza. We deliver tradition, taste, and the toppings New Jersey loves most.
Looking for the best 24-hour pizza in Rutherford, NJ?
Tap below to call or order online. Bella Pizza is open 24/7 in Rutherford — your favorite local slice is waiting!