When it comes to great pizza in Hasbrouck Heights, locals know there’s no shortage of flavor. At Bella Pizza, we’ve proudly earned a reputation as one of the closest and most loved pizza shops in the Hasbrouck Heights area, with customers also coming in from nearby Moonachie, Carlstadt, and Hackensack.
But even in a region where pizza reigns supreme, there’s always room to explore — and once in a while, we stumble across a story that reminds us just how rich and surprising the pizza world really is.
Today, we’re spotlighting a lesser-known East Coast pizza town that’s gaining attention fast — and sharing why Bella Pizza remains a staple in Hasbrouck Heights and beyond.
Order More & Save!
3.00 Off any order of 30.00 or more! 5.00 Off any order of 50.00 or more!
8.00 Off any order of 80.00 or more!
Scranton, PA – The East Coast’s Hidden Pizza Gem
Believe it or not, while cities like Brooklyn, Naples, and the Jersey Shore are considered pizza capitals, a small Pennsylvania town is suddenly turning heads: Scranton.
Yes — the same Scranton made famous by The Office.
According to pizza fans and culinary reviewers — including our own team at Bella Pizza, proudly serving the best pizza in Carlstadt, Moonachie, and Hackensack — Scranton’s pizza scene has recently exploded, thanks in part to something called the Lackawanna County Pizza Trail.
With more than 160 pizzerias in the area, locals were asked to vote for their favorites. The top 62 were featured on a trail map that’s become a full-on tourist attraction — and a major bragging point for this former coal mining town.
Even celebrities like Donald Trump, Dr. Oz, and Dave Portnoy (of Barstool Sports’ One Bite Pizza Reviews) have visited to sample what’s now known as Old Forge pizza.
What Makes Old Forge Pizza So Different?
If you’re used to New York-style thin crust or Jersey tomato pies, Old Forge pizza might surprise you. According to our team at Bella Pizza — known as the closest and best pizza shop in Hasbrouck Heights — Old Forge pizza has a few signature traits:
It’s served in rectangular trays, not round pies
A single piece is called a “cut,” not a slice
The crust is lighter than a typical Sicilian, with a crispy base and soft, chewy center
Red pizza often includes a slightly sweet sauce — sometimes with chopped onions
The cheese blend is unique — think mozzarella, cheddar, Cooper, and American
White pizza features a top and bottom crust, stuffed with melted cheese
There’s even “black pizza,” with no sauce, just cheese, peppers, olives, and onions
It’s truly its own style — not New York, not Chicago — but a whole new experience. And its roots go deep: legend says it began in 1926 with an Italian grandmother who served rectangular pizzas in shirt boxes to coal miners heading home from work.
Back in Hasbrouck Heights: Why Bella Pizza Still Leads
While we love discovering regional styles and celebrating local legends, nothing beats coming home to fresh, hot, handmade pizza in Hasbrouck Heights.
At Bella Pizza, we combine the best of traditional Italian recipes, fresh ingredients, and family-friendly service to bring you pies that satisfy every craving — whether you’re a fan of thin crust, Sicilian, or even inspired by Old Forge’s bold variations.
So if you’re looking for the closest pizza shop in Hasbrouck Heights, there’s no need to travel far. Just stop by Bella Pizza for:
Late-night pizza runs
Family dinners
Custom toppings and classic favorites
Dine-in, takeout, or fast delivery
Visit Bella Pizza — Hasbrouck Heights’ Closest Pizza Shop with the Biggest Flavor
Before you plan a road trip to Scranton (though we recommend it if you love pizza adventures), come visit us right here at Bella Pizza in Hasbrouck Heights. We’re proud to bring you local flavor with global inspiration — and always deliver with quality, heart, and a whole lot of cheese.
Come taste why Hasbrouck Heights calls Bella Pizza its favorite neighborhood pizzeria.
Looking for the best 24-hour pizza in Rutherford, NJ?
Tap below to call or order online. Bella Pizza is open 24/7 in Rutherford — your favorite local slice is waiting!