When you think of great pizza, New Jersey is always in the conversation—and for good reason. From its flavorful tomato pies to its signature crispy crust, Garden State pizza stands in a league of its own. And nowhere is that more evident than at Bella Pizza, proudly known as the best pizzeria in Moonachie, NJ.
Ask any local, and they’ll tell you—it’s not just the crust or the sauce, it’s the toppings that elevate Jersey pizza to greatness. Whether it’s hand-crushed tomatoes, locally sourced sausage, or veggies straight from nearby Italian markets, Bella Pizza combines it all with perfection.
In this article, the team behind the best pizza delivery in Carlstadt breaks down the top 4 most-loved toppings that keep New Jersey pizza lovers coming back for more.
Order More & Save!
3.00 Off any order of 30.00 or more! 5.00 Off any order of 50.00 or more!
8.00 Off any order of 80.00 or more!
1. Sausage – The Undisputed Favorite
While pepperoni may dominate nationwide, in Moonachie and surrounding towns like Carlstadt, sausage reigns supreme. According to the experts at Bella Pizza, sausage pizza has become a generational favorite, often ordered for family dinners and weekend get-togethers. Whether it’s crumbled Italian sausage or thick-cut slices, the savory, herb-infused flavor pairs beautifully with mozzarella and Jersey’s signature sweet tomato sauce.
2. Mushrooms – The Surprise Powerhouse
Mushrooms might not be the most hyped topping around the U.S., but New Jersey pizza lovers know just how underrated they are. At Bella Pizza, often hailed as the best pizza delivery Moonachie has to offer, customers can’t get enough of mushrooms—especially when paired with sausage. Their earthy richness and meaty texture make them the go-to topping for vegetarians and meat-eaters alike.
3. Pepperoni – The Classic Crowd-Pleaser
There’s a reason you see pepperoni on every pizza emoji—it’s the universal symbol of pizza. And while New Jersey has its own local favorites, pepperoni still holds strong. Bella Pizza’s signature pepperoni slice features perfectly curled, crispy edges and a light spicy kick that blends beautifully with their slightly sweet Jersey-style sauce. It’s the ultimate comfort food and a must-try at the best pizzeria in Moonachie.
4. Spinach – The White Slice Secret
White pizza, known for skipping the tomato sauce and relying on olive oil, ricotta, and mozzarella, is a favorite among pizza purists. And when it comes to white slices in New Jersey, spinach is the topping of choice. According to the team at Bella Pizza, spinach adds a subtle depth and richness that makes the white slice something special. It’s light, elegant, and uniquely New Jersey.
Bella Pizza: The Best Pizzeria Moonachie Locals Rely On
What makes Bella Pizza stand out in Moonachie and Carlstadt isn’t just the toppings or the dough—it’s the care, the tradition, and the unmatched consistency. They use only the finest ingredients, sourced locally whenever possible, and craft every pizza like it’s their last.
“Our customers know exactly what they’re getting every time,” says the owner. “That’s why we’re proud to be called the best pizzeria in Moonachie—because we deliver flavor, quality, and heart in every pie.”
Try the Best Pizza in Carlstadt & Moonachie Today
Whether you’re craving a classic sausage-and-mushroom combo, a white slice with spinach, or just a good old-fashioned pepperoni pie, Bella Pizza is the spot locals trust. Dine-in, take out, or enjoy fast and reliable delivery right to your door.
Order now from the best pizzeria Moonachie has to offer—and taste why New Jersey pizza is winning the nation over.
Looking for the best 24-hour pizza in Moonachie & Carlstadt?
Tap below to call or order online. Bella Pizza is open 24/7 in Moonachie — your favorite local slice is waiting!