If there’s one thing New York City does better than almost anywhere else — it’s pizza. From the bustling streets of Manhattan to quiet corners of Queens, NYC is packed with pizzerias serving up slices that range from legendary to experimental.
At Bella Pizza, we proudly serve towns like Wood Ridge, Carlstadt, and East Rutherford, just minutes outside the city — bringing the same level of care and flavor that defines authentic New York-style pizza. And as pizza lovers ourselves, we understand how diverse and dynamic the NYC pizza scene really is.
So whether you’re a local in North Jersey or a tourist exploring the five boroughs, here’s a rundown of the most iconic pizza styles in New York City, explained by the team behind some of the best pizza delivery near NYC.
Order More & Save!
3.00 Off any order of 30.00 or more! 5.00 Off any order of 50.00 or more!
8.00 Off any order of 80.00 or more!
1. Coal & Wood Oven Pizza
This is the original New York-style pizza — thin, charred, foldable, and served fresh from a high-heat oven. These slices have a crispy, blistered crust, a light spread of tomato sauce, and fresh mozzarella that melts just right.
According to our team at Bella Pizza — known for the best pizza delivery in Carlstadt and Wood Ridge — the ovens used in this style are part of what makes it so legendary. In NYC, coal-burning ovens are grandfathered in, meaning only historic pizzerias can still legally operate them. The high heat creates that signature crunch and flavor.
In the tri-state area, wood-fired ovens are more common (like the ones we use at Bella Pizza), which burn slightly cooler than coal but offer a deep, smoky char and crispy texture. Whether you’re eating in Brooklyn or just across the bridge in East Rutherford, this style is a fan favorite.
2. The Classic New York Slice
Ask anyone across the U.S. what a “New York slice” looks like, and this is it — thin, wide, cheesy, and foldable.
At Bella Pizza, our customers from East Rutherford to Carlstadt often crave this iconic style. It’s the perfect slice to grab on the go, eat while walking, or enjoy as a quick lunch break. Simple toppings, sweet tomato sauce, and that classic NYC crust make it a forever favorite — whether you’re in Manhattan or right here in North Jersey.
3. Sicilian Pizza
Thick, square, and hearty — Sicilian pizza is the complete opposite of the standard NYC slice, but just as beloved.
Traditionally rooted in Sicily, this pizza features a fluffy, airy dough, baked in a rectangular pan, topped with lots of sauce, cheese, and robust toppings. At Bella Pizza, known for the best Italian food in East Rutherford, Sicilian-style pies are perfect for customers who want a more filling, indulgent slice.
One of the most popular versions of this style can be found at Prince Street Pizza in Manhattan — home of the double-cupped pepperoni. But you can enjoy that same satisfying square closer to home, thanks to local spots like Bella Pizza.
4. Neapolitan Pizza
If you’re craving a more traditional Italian pizza, Neapolitan is your answer.
With its soft center, lightly blistered crust, and use of fresh ingredients like San Marzano tomatoes and buffalo mozzarella, this is the pizza you’ll find in Naples, Italy — and at many upscale NYC pizzerias. According to the team at Bella Pizza, delivering to Wood Ridge and beyond, Neapolitan pizza is ideal for foodies who want an authentic, artisanal experience.
It’s also a favorite for dine-in customers who appreciate balance, bold flavor, and beautiful presentation.
Pizza Styles Galore — Just Minutes from New York City
Whether you’re enjoying a sidewalk slice in Brooklyn or having pizza night delivered to your home in Carlstadt or Wood Ridge, the New York City pizza experience is alive and well in the tri-state area.
At Bella Pizza, we’re proud to bring the same flavor, tradition, and attention to detail that you’d find in a Manhattan pizzeria — just without the long lines or city parking.
Order Now from Bella Pizza – The Tri-State’s Trusted Pizza Delivery Near NYC
Looking for New York-style pizza without crossing the bridge? Bella Pizza has you covered.
We offer:
Classic NY slices and Sicilian squares
Wood-fired pies with crisp, chewy crusts
Fresh ingredients, authentic recipes
Fast delivery to Wood Ridge, Carlstadt, East Rutherford, and nearby towns
Whether you want a single slice or a full pie for the family, Bella Pizza brings NYC flavor right to your doorstep.
Visit us at 197 Boulevard, Hasbrouck Heights, NJ – Just Minutes from NYC!
Looking for the best 24-hour pizza in Rutherford, NJ?
Tap below to call or order online. Bella Pizza is open 24/7 in Rutherford — your favorite local slice is waiting!